Pd-based bimetallic catalysts for parahydrogen-induced polarization in heterogeneous hydrogenations
Production of hyperpolarized catalyst-free gases and liquids by heterogeneous hydrogenation with parahydrogen can be useful for various technical as well as biomedical applications, including in vivo studies, investigations of mechanisms of industrially important catalytic processes, enrichment of nuclear spin isomers of polyatomic gases, and more. In this regard, the wide systematic search for heterogeneous catalysts effective in pairwise H2 addition required for the observation of parahydrogen-induced polarization (PHIP) effects is crucial. Here in this work we demonstrate the competitive advantage of Pd-based bimetallic catalysts for PHIP in heterogeneous hydrogenations (HET-PHIP). The dilution of catalytically active Pd with less active Ag or In atoms provides the formation of atomically dispersed Pd1 sites on the surface of Pd-based bimetallic catalysts, which are significantly more selective toward pairwise H2 addition compared to the monometallic Pd. Furthermore, the choice of the dilution metal (Ag or In) has a pronounced effect on the efficiency of bimetallic catalysts in HET-PHIP, as revealed by comparing Pd-Ag and Pd-In bimetallic catalysts.
Among the nuclear spin hyperpolarization (HP) techniques that are currently becoming very popular in NMR and MRI, parahydrogen-based approaches such as parahydrogen-induced polarization (PHIP) and signal amplification by reversible exchange (SABRE) are of particular interest (Adams et al., 2009; Duckett and Mewis, 2012; Green et al., 2012; Iali et al., 2018; Reineri et al., 2015). They are relatively easy to implement, and at the same time they compete successfully with other powerful HP techniques such as DNP (dynamic nuclear polarization; Ardenkjaer-Larsen, 2016; Jannin et al., 2019; Lumata et al., 2015; Rossini, 2018; Zhao et al., 2018). Since the first report of the PHIP effect (Bowers and Weitekamp, 1987), the majority of such studies are based on the homogeneous catalysis by transition-metal complexes in solution. Many such catalysts can achieve pairwise addition of H2 to a substrate and/or to a catalytically active center, which is usually a prerequisite for parahydrogen-based hyperpolarization. At the same time, there are several significant reasons why PHIP via heterogeneous hydrogenations (HET-PHIP) (Balu et al., 2009; Gutmann et al., 2010; Kaltschnee et al., 2019; Kovtunov et al., 2013, 2016, 2020a) can be advantageous. In particular, in vivo applications certainly require catalyst-free hyperpolarized fluids. Removal of potentially toxic transition-metal complexes utilized in the homogeneous implementations of PHIP and SABRE, while possible (Cavallari et al., 2020; Kidd et al., 2018; Knecht et al., 2021), still remains one of the primary challenges to be solved. In this respect, solid heterogeneous catalysts can be filtered out much faster; thus, higher polarization levels can be available upon injection. HET-PHIP is also directly applicable to the production of HP gases (Ariyasingha et al., 2020; Kovtunov et al., 2020b; Salnikov et al., 2019), which appears promising as a means to provide inhalable HP contrast agents for in vivo use in lung MRI. Furthermore, heterogeneous processes are most suited for the production of continuous streams of catalyst-free HP fluids (Kovtunov et al., 2014), which is expected to be useful for various technical as well as biomedical applications.
A separate yet strongly related field of research is the application of HP substances in the studies of chemical processes. In particular, PHIP has proven useful in the mechanistic studies of homogeneous catalytic reactions that involve H2 (Duckett and Sleigh, 1999). In this respect, extension of the parahydrogen-based NMR signal enhancement to the mechanistic studies of heterogeneous hydrogenations and related processes (Du et al., 2020; Salnikov et al., 2015, 2018; Zhivonitko et al., 2016) is highly desirable. This is because heterogeneous catalysts and processes by far predominate in modern large-scale industrial catalysis, and at the same time they are significantly more sophisticated by their nature. Developing enhanced analytical tools for such studies is a challenging but rewarding task.
Finally, the HET-PHIP approach can prove useful for addressing yet another challenge of modern science, namely, the production/enrichment of nuclear spin isomers of polyatomic molecules (NSIMs). As mentioned above, the addition of p-H2 to a substrate or intermediate usually has to be pairwise for the correlated spin state of the nascent H atoms to be carried over to a reaction product or intermediate. However, if the two H atoms remain magnetically equivalent there, their correlated spin state, even if preserved, is not immediately revealed as an NMR signal enhancement. This has been demonstrated in numerous studies in solution in the context of the long-lived spin states (Levitt, 2019). Furthermore, hydrogenation of symmetric gaseous substrates is a potential route to the enrichment of their NSIMs, as successfully demonstrated earlier for ethylene in a heterogeneous hydrogenation of acetylene with parahydrogen (Zhivonitko et al., 2013). This development is rather significant – while there are several known methods for enrichment or separation of NSIMs of polyatomic molecules (Chapovsky and Hermans, 1999; Kilaj et al., 2018; Krüger et al., 2018), to date none of them is able to produce sufficient quantities of an enriched polyatomic gas for NMR signal enhancement applications, including the reported production of the singlet spin state of 15N2 by SABRE in solution (Bae et al., 2018). Thus, the work of Zhivonitko et al. (2013) so far remains the only demonstration of NMR signal enhancement derived from a NSIM-enriched polyatomic gas.
Based on the major recent progress achieved in p-H2-based hyperpolarized NMR, it can be reasonably expected that potential utilization of NSIM-enriched polyatomic molecules can advance this field of research and practice much further, by significantly expanding the scope of reactions, substrates and products for the production of HP agents for in vivo use as well as extending the advanced mechanistic studies to new classes of highly important catalytic processes. This, however, does not exhaust the list of activities that would benefit from the facile production/enrichment of NSIMs of polyatomic molecules. In modern science, of significant interest are the properties of NSIMs, including their interconversion processes (Chapovsky and Hermans, 1999) and NSIM behavior upon phase transitions (Curl et al., 1966; Hama et al., 2018); the NSIM-related selection rules in molecular spectroscopy (Kanamori et al., 2017; Ozier et al., 1970) and upon chemical transformations (Hu et al., 2020; Kilaj et al., 2018; Oka, 2004); NSIMs in astrophysics and astrochemistry research (Hama and Watanabe, 2013; Hily-Blant et al., 2018; Shinnaka et al., 2016; Tielens, 2013); and more.
To date, however, most heterogeneous catalysts demonstrated a limited efficiency in the pairwise hydrogen addition, in some cases low yields of the desired product, or both (Balu et al., 2009; Gutmann et al., 2010; Kaltschnee et al., 2019; Kovtunov et al., 2013, 2016, 2020a). Better heterogeneous catalysts are thus required, something which is constantly searched for in heterogeneous catalysis in general as more active and selective industrial catalysts have a major impact on all areas of our life. One of the powerful recent trends is the exploration of the so-called single-site and single-atom heterogeneous catalysts (Liu et al., 2018; Samantaray et al., 2020), which often outperform other catalyst types in terms of product selectivity and can ensure a much more efficient use of active metals, reducing the costs and contributing to a cleaner chemical industry. Selectivity issues are highly important in essentially all catalytic processes; in particular, this includes semihydrogenation of alkynes in the presence of alkenes without converting them into alkanes.
One promising type of catalysts for selective hydrogenation processes are bimetallic systems composed of two different metals either as an alloy or in an intermetallic form. Dilution of a more active metal with a less active one significantly modifies the geometric and electronic structure of an active center, providing isolated active metal atoms at high dilutions (Hannagan et al., 2020). It was demonstrated previously that in addition to an enhanced chemical selectivity to an alkene, Pd site isolation by In in the intermetallic 1 wt % Pd-In catalyst provides an enhanced selectivity to pairwise addition of H2 to an alkyne (Burueva et al., 2018).
However, so far the vast majority of reported HET-PHIP experiments involving supported metal catalysts were performed with monometallic systems, whereas the potential advantages of bimetallic nanoparticles in this context were addressed in very few studies. In this work, for the first time we directly compare monometallic and bimetallic Pd-based catalysts in the selective hydrogenation of propyne to propene with parahydrogen. The results clearly indicate that the bimetallic Pd-Ag catalyst largely outperforms its monometallic counterparts not only in the overall activity and selectivity toward propene but also in the pairwise selectivity of hydrogen addition as revealed by significantly larger NMR signal enhancements for propene. Furthermore, the choice of the dilution partner has a pronounced effect on the efficiency of bimetallic catalysts in HET-PHIP, as revealed by comparing Pd-Ag and Pd-In bimetallic catalysts.
2.1 Catalyst preparation and characterization
A catalyst was obtained via incipient wetness impregnation of Al2O3 (Sasol, specific surface area of 56 m2 g−1) preliminarily calcined at 550 ∘C in flowing air for 3 h with an aqueous solution of Pd(NO3)2 and AgNO3. To prepare this solution, 0.153 g of silver(I) nitrate (Merck, 204390-10G) was dissolved in 0.7059 g of 10 wt % palladium(II) nitrate solution (Aldrich, 380040-50ML). After that, 0.25 mL of distilled water was added. The resulting solution was used for impregnation of 1.5 g of Al2O3. The product was dried overnight at room temperature in air and then reduced in 5 vol % flow (∼100 mL min−1) at 550 ∘C for 3 h. The temperature was increased from room temperature to 550 ∘C with a 3.5 ∘C min−1 ramp.
The reference catalyst samples ( and ) were also prepared by incipient wetness impregnation with an aqueous solution of the corresponding nitrates. The impregnated samples were dried in air at room temperature overnight followed by the reduction in 5 vol % (∼100 mL min−1) flow at 550 ∘C for 3 h. The detailed preparation procedures of the catalysts used in this work are described elsewhere (Markov et al., 2016; Smirnova et al., 2019).
For preparation of the catalyst, an aqueous solution of binuclear acetate complex Pd(OOCMe)4In(OOCMe) was used as a precursor. The preparation procedure of this complex is described elsewhere (Stolarov et al., 2018). To obtain the impregnating solution, 0.164 g of Pd(OOCMe)4In(OOCMe) was dissolved in 4.75 mL of distilled water. After that, 1.45 g of Al2O3 (Sasol, specific surface area of 56 m2 g−1) preliminarily calcined in flowing air (550 ∘C, 3 h) was impregnated by 0.95 mL of the solution followed by overnight drying at room temperature. The impregnation and drying procedure was repeated five times to overcome the insufficient solubility of the complex and achieve the required metal content with the “dry” impregnation method used. The resulting material was reduced at 600 ∘C for 3 h in flowing 5 vol % (∼100 mL min−1). The temperature was increased from room temperature to 600 ∘C with a 3.5 ∘C min−1 ramp.
The inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES) spectra were recorded on a Baird PS-6 plasma spectrometer. According to ICP-AES data, the catalyst sample contained 2 wt % of Pd and 6 wt % of Ag; the catalyst contained 2 wt % of Pd and 2 wt % of In. The reference catalyst sample contained 2.5 wt % of Pd; the catalyst contained 6 wt % of Ag. The Pd-Ag catalyst was extensively characterized in recent work by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), diffuse reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy of chemisorbed CO (DRIFTS-CO), temperature-programmed reduction with H2 (H2-TPR), and hydrogen temperature-programmed desorption (H2-TPD) (Rassolov et al., 2020b). The structure of the catalyst was studied in detail by TEM, DRIFTS-CO, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (Burueva et al., 2018; Markov et al., 2019; Mashkovsky et al., 2018).
2.2 Catalytic activity tests
Commercially available hydrogen and propyne gases were used without additional purification. For catalytic tests, propyne was premixed with p-H2-enriched hydrogen in the molar ratio of 1:4. Hydrogen gas was enriched with the para isomer up to 87.0 %–90.5 % using a Bruker BPHG-90 parahydrogen generator. The catalyst (30 mg, density of 0.67 g cm−3) was placed in the middle of a stainless-steel tubular reactor ( in. o.d., 4.2 mm i.d., 20 cm total length) between two plugs of fiberglass tissue. The bimetallic catalysts (Pd-Ag, Pd-In) as well as monometallic Ag catalyst were reduced in H2 flow at 550 ∘C for 1 h before the catalytic tests. The catalyst was reduced in H2 flow at 300 ∘C for 1 h. The catalyst was cooled down to the desired reaction temperature without H2 flow termination and the p-H2 mixture was introduced to the catalyst. The reactor was positioned outside an NMR magnet, and the substrate gas mixture was supplied to the reactor; then the resulting mixture was supplied to the standard screw-cap 10 mm o.d. NMR tube (Merck, Z271969) positioned inside the NMR spectrometer for detection (ALTADENA experimental protocol; Pravica and Weitekamp, 1988) through a in. o.d. ( in. i.d.) PTFE capillary. In the NMR tube, the gas mixture was flowing from the bottom to the top and then to the vent through a in. o.d. (5.8 mm i.d.) PTFE tubing connected with screw-ending of the NMR tube. All hydrogenation experiments were performed at ambient pressure (ca. 101 kPa). The reactor was heated with a tube furnace, and the temperature was varied from 100 to 300 ∘C (in the case of Pd-Ag catalyst) and up to 500 ∘C (Pd-In catalyst) in 100 ∘C increments (the heating rate was 10 ∘C min−1). The temperature was controlled with a K-type thermocouple placed immediately adjacent to the catalyst bed on the external side of the reactor. The reaction was conducted in a continuous-flow regime with the reactor outflow continuously supplied to the probe of an NMR spectrometer and analyzed by 1H NMR. The gas flow rate was controlled using an Aalborg rotameter and varied stepwise from 1.3 to 3.8 mL s−1. The gas flow was periodically interrupted in order to acquire stopped-flow 1H NMR spectra for evaluating conversion and selectivity. After the introduction of the substrate gas mixture to the catalyst and establishment of the steady-state regime, 1H NMR spectra were recorded on a 300 MHz Bruker AV NMR spectrometer using a rf (radio frequency) pulse. A 10 mm BBO 300 MHz Bruker probe head was used.
The products of propyne hydrogenation are propene and propane; at high reaction temperatures (≥400 ∘C), propyne can isomerize to propadiene. The propyne conversion value (X) at a certain flow rate and temperature was calculated as the molar ratio of the reaction products (propene, propane, and propadiene) to the sum of products and unreacted propyne. The selectivity to propene (Spropene) was calculated as the molar ratio of propene to the sum of propene, propane, and propadiene. Both values were evaluated from 1H NMR spectra acquired in thermal equilibrium after a complete relaxation of hyperpolarization. The error of the quantitative analysis of gas-phase NMR spectra was estimated as 10 %.
The activities of different catalysts in pairwise hydrogen addition were compared using the “apparent signal enhancement” (SE) values, evaluated as the ratio between the integral of the enhanced NMR signal of the propene CH group and the integral of the corresponding signal for thermally polarized propene. Selectivity toward pairwise addition of H2 is the estimated measure of the contribution of the pairwise H2 addition to the overall mechanism of hydrogenation which is predominantly non-pairwise. It can be evaluated as the ratio of the apparent SE to the largest theoretically possible enhancement under conditions which ensure pairwise H2 addition exclusively. For 1H polarization at 298 K, magnetic field of 7.1 T, and 90.5 % fraction of p-H2, the theoretical SE equals ∼35 880 (Bowers, 2007). The relaxation losses during the transfer of hyperpolarized propene to the NMR spectrometer for detection and the effect of signal suppression in the NMR spectra of the continuously flowing gas mixture were not taken into account. So, the presented apparent SE values are lower estimates.
Here in this work we studied the catalytic behavior of different Pd-based bimetallic catalysts (Pd-Ag and Pd-In) in the selective gas-phase hydrogenation of propyne with parahydrogen.
First, the synergetic effect of Pd-Ag catalyst in HET-PHIP is addressed, then the behavior of this catalyst is compared to that of Pd-In, and after that factors affecting pairwise H2 addition selectivity are discussed.
3.1 Synergetic effect of catalyst in HET-PHIP
The catalytic activity of the monometallic reference catalysts (6 wt % and 2 wt % ) was explored first. It was found that no hydrogenation products were observed in the 1H NMR spectra during the attempted propyne hydrogenation over catalyst for the entire reaction temperature range, indicating that catalytic activity of is negligible under the experimental conditions. In contrast, the catalyst showed an excellent activity – even at a relatively low reaction temperature of 100 ∘C and the flow rate of 1.3 mL s−1, the propyne conversion reached 100 %. However, the monometallic catalyst exhibited poor selectivity toward propene (Table 1). Slightly higher selectivity values at high gas mixture flow rates are explained by the lower contact times between the reacting gas and the catalyst. In addition, a declining alkene selectivity at higher alkyne conversions is a known problem associated with unmodified Pd catalysts.
Modification of Pd catalysts with a second metal, which is typically less active or even completely inactive in hydrogenation, leads to a synergetic effect in catalytic activity – bimetallic Pd-based catalysts usually demonstrate enhanced selectivity and stability (Bond, 2005). Here we show that the introduction of Ag atoms inactive in propyne hydrogenation to Pd and formation of a bimetallic Pd-Ag catalyst (2 wt % of Pd and 6 wt % Ag) dramatically enhances its catalytic behavior. The Pd-Ag catalyst demonstrated a significantly higher selectivity toward propene with a comparable conversion in propyne hydrogenation; e.g., at 100 ∘C and 1.3 mL s−1 both Pd and Pd-Ag catalysts showed 100 % conversion, but the Pd-Ag catalyst showed higher selectivity compared to the monometallic Pd catalyst (75 % vs. 45 %).
Such catalytic behavior is typical for bimetallic catalysts and can be associated with suppression of the formation of the palladium hydride phase, which is a known hydrogen source responsible for the undesired unselective hydrogenation of alkynes and alkenes to alkanes (Armbrüster et al., 2012). Nevertheless, the enhanced catalytic performance of Pd-Ag catalyst can be also explained by the fact that atomically dispersed Pd sites (Pd1) isolated from each other by inactive Ag atoms can be achieved at high dilutions and stabilized during high-temperature prereduction in H2 (400–550 ∘C) (Pei et al., 2015). The authors associate the higher selectivity of isolated Pd1 sites over the Pd-Ag catalyst with the decrease in the heat of adsorption of alkene compared to that on a monometallic Pd catalyst. The differentiation between the effects associated with the formation of isolated Pd1 sites and the suppression of the formation of palladium hydrides for Pd-Ag catalysts with different ratio was thoroughly studied in previous works (Rassolov et al., 2020a, b). It was found that an increase in the Ag content in the composition of bimetallic Pd-Ag nanoparticles hinders the formation of palladium hydrides, which is completely suppressed at a ratio of ≥1. Analysis of the structural stability of isolated Pd1 sites has shown that the stability of such sites can be provided by an increase in the ratio to ≥2.
The significant dilution of Pd atoms with Ag ( =3) in this study ensures the formation of isolated Pd1 sites, which is confirmed by IR spectroscopy of adsorbed CO (Rassolov et al., 2020b). In an analogy with transition-metal complexes in solution, the presence of isolated Pd1 sites on the Pd-Ag catalyst surface can be expected to result in an enhanced activity of the bimetallic Pd-Ag catalyst in pairwise hydrogen addition. This expectation is indeed borne out by the experimental observations. Both monometallic Pd and bimetallic Pd-Ag catalysts were active in pairwise H2 addition in propyne hydrogenation with parahydrogen (Fig. 1). The enhanced NMR signals from CH (signal no. 4 in Fig. 1) and CH2 protons (signals no. 3 and no. 5) of propene were observed.
The reference monometallic 2 wt % catalyst demonstrated very low 1H NMR signal enhancement factors for the CH proton of propene, with SE values not exceeding 3 over the entire reaction temperature range. However, the dilution of Pd with Ag atoms allowed an ∼4-fold increase in SE (up to 13) for the Pd-Ag catalyst (Table 2). The moderate activity of bimetallic Pd-Ag catalyst in pairwise H2 addition may be associated with its tendency to the surface transformations – in an earlier work it was shown that on the surface of Pd-Ag catalyst a transformation of a part of monoatomic Pd1 centers to multiatomic Pdn surface clusters takes place as a result of Pd atoms migration on the surface upon treatment with CO (Stakheev et al., 2018) due to an adsorbate-induced segregation phenomenon. Most likely, analogous surface transformations are initiated by the strong adsorption of propyne. In the previous study it was found that such a surface transformation almost did not change catalyst selectivity in a liquid-phase hydrogenation process; however, our results clearly show that pairwise hydrogen addition is an extremely sensitive reaction and can be potentially used as a marker of the structural transformations of the catalyst surface.
3.2 Effect of second metal M (Ag vs. In) on the activity of catalysts in HET-PHIP
As it was shown above, the stability of atomically dispersed Pd1 sites on the surface may have a great impact on the efficiency of bimetallic catalysts in HET-PHIP. In order to differentiate the stability effect, Pd atoms were diluted with a different metal (In). The 2 wt % Pd-In catalyst ( =1) was also tested in propyne hydrogenation with parahydrogen. In these experiments, the slightly lower p-H2 enrichment was used; the p-H2 fraction was 87.0 % (instead of 90.5 % in the case of Pd, Ag, and Pd-Ag catalytic activity tests). Therefore, for the sake of comparison, the apparent values of signal enhancement for the Pd-In catalyst were extrapolated to the 90.5 % p-H2 fraction (see “SE corrected” column in Table 3). The Pd-In catalyst clearly demonstrated a higher activity in pairwise hydrogen addition compared to the Pd-Ag catalyst; e.g., at 200 ∘C and 3.8 mL s−1 the signal enhancement was 88, i.e., much larger than for Pd-Ag (13). The comparison of hyperpolarized 1H NMR spectra acquired during propyne hydrogenation over Pd-Ag and Pd-In catalysts is presented in Fig. 2; the spectra are shown on the same vertical scale. It is interesting to note that the Pd-In catalyst demonstrated also a higher propene selectivity along with higher activity in HET-PHIP – at 200 ∘C and 1.3 mL s−1 the selectivity toward propene reached 98 %, while for Pd-Ag it was 75 %. The highest values of SE were observed at 400 ∘C – at 3.8 mL s−1 the signal enhancement was 113 for Pd-In (shown in bold in Table 3).
* SE values corrected to the 90.5 % parahydrogen fraction.
3.3 Factors affecting pairwise H2 addition selectivity
The NMR signal enhancements observed in this study are rather moderate, and higher values have been achieved in HET-PHIP experiments with bimetallic catalysts in the past. For instance, higher SE values were observed in the previous work for the 1 wt % catalyst (Burueva et al., 2018), which is likely associated with a different metal loading. Also, substantially higher enhancements were reported for Pt−Sn intermetallic nanoparticles confined within mesoporous silica (Du et al., 2020). However, it should be stressed that the activity of the Pd, Pd-Ag, and Pd-In catalysts is compared here using the apparent-signal-enhancement values. The catalytic tests were carried out under the ALTADENA experimental protocol (Pravica and Weitekamp, 1988), implying that hydrogenation reaction proceeds outside an NMR spectrometer, with subsequent delivery of catalytic reactor outflow over a substantial distance to the probe of the NMR spectrometer for detection. Hence, the apparent signal enhancements evaluated for Pd-based catalysts presented in Tables 2 and 3 are lower estimates of the actual values of initial enhancements, underestimated (and possibly significantly) because hyperpolarization relaxation dramatically reduces the intensities of enhanced 1H NMR signals of propene during the transfer. The accurate analysis of processes leading to polarization losses in the ALTADENA experiment (non-adiabaticity of magnetic field change during the transfer of hyperpolarized product from the Earth's magnetic field, the relaxation losses in both high and low magnetic fields, etc.) performed previously (Barskiy et al., 2015; Burueva et al., 2018) indicates that the apparent signal enhancement factors are significantly reduced due to the abovementioned causes – by 1 order of magnitude or possibly more. Also, during the delivery of hyperpolarized products to the NMR probe, the polarization is redistributed in the Earth's magnetic field, leading to the observation of polarized signal of the CH3− group of propene (negative signal no. 6 in blue spectrum, which was acquired while the Pd-Ag catalyst was used), which cannot be polarized directly by pairwise hydrogen addition to propyne. In addition, Fig. 1 clearly shows that for both Pd and Pd-Ag catalysts, the broad signal at 4.5 ppm (from orthohydrogen) emerges in the 1H NMR spectra, meaning that ortho–para conversion of H2 takes place on these catalysts. The concrete mechanism of this process and its impact on pairwise hydrogen addition is unclear at present, and further detailed investigation is required. Overall, these and other factors lead to the underestimation of the true selectivity to pairwise H2 addition over the catalysts studied, which can be rather significant. At the same time, while minimization of relaxation losses is very important for applications of HET-PHIP, the primary objective of this work is the exploration of how the nature of a catalyst affects its selectivity toward pairwise H2 addition to a substrate.
The Pd-In bimetallic catalyst is shown to provide a significantly more pronounced PHIP effect compared to the Pd-Ag system. One potential reason for the inferior behavior of the Pd-Ag catalyst is already mentioned earlier, namely, the restructuring of the surface under reactive conditions in the presence of adsorbates such as propyne and H2. In contrast to the Pd-Ag solid solution alloy, the Pd-In surface structure is more stable owing to the high formation enthalpy of the Pd-In intermetallic compound, which prevents surface segregation even in the presence of adsorbates.
However, there are potentially other contributing factors. While the catalyst was completely inactive in propyne hydrogenation, this does not mean that hydrogenation cannot proceed on the Ag atoms of the Pd-Ag catalyst. Indeed, the primary reason for the inactivity of metals such as Ag and Au in catalytic hydrogenations is known to be their inability to efficiently activate H2 due to a large activation energy barrier for dissociative H2 chemisorption on these metals. In bimetallic catalysts containing Ag or Au in combination with a platinum group metal such as Pd, a new reaction channel becomes available. It involves dissociative and often essentially barrierless chemisorption of H2 on a Pd atom or cluster followed by spillover of the resulting hydrogen atoms to the other metal (e.g., Ag or Au), which can then efficiently incorporate atomic hydrogen into the hydrogenation product (Hannagan et al., 2020). As hydrogen spillover tends to randomize hydrogen atoms on the catalyst surface, such a hydrogenation mechanism cannot achieve pairwise H2 addition to a substrate. This may be an additional reason why the Pd-Ag combination is inferior to Pd-In in the production of HET-PHIP. Furthermore, in addition to the ensemble effects associated with the isolation of individual Pd atoms as catalytically active centers when Pd is diluted with a less active metal, the electronic structure of Pd is altered upon dilution, and this alteration will significantly depend on the electronic (e.g., electron donating or withdrawing) properties of the added metal.
Importantly, in the current study we show that Pd-containing bimetallic catalysts significantly outperform monometallic Pd catalysts in terms of the achievable NMR signal enhancements in heterogeneous hydrogenations of unsaturated compounds with parahydrogen. At the same time, they maintain very high activity as well as hydrogenation selectivity toward semihydrogenation of alkynes. This is in contrast to the behavior of Pt-based catalysts reported earlier (Du et al., 2020), which demonstrated a significant decline in activity upon progressive dilution with Sn, combined with usually lower selectivity of Pt in the hydrogenation of alkynes to alkenes compared to Pd. This is in agreement with the fact that Pd-based catalysts are preferred in industrial hydrogenations to achieve high reaction yields and product selectivities. Furthermore, the results presented above clearly show that the choice of the dilution metal for bimetallic catalysts has a pronounced effect on their efficiency in HET-PHIP. This efficiency is governed by multiple factors, including possible catalyst surface restructuring under reactive conditions, electronic effects exerted by the secondary metal on the catalytically active component, and involvement of additional reaction pathways such as “metal–ligand cooperation” when both metals are involved in the hydrogenation event. Further detailed studies are required to establish which factors are the most relevant, and these will eventually provide guidance to achieving the ultimate NMR signal enhancements in HET-PHIP experiments.
Further progress in the development of parahydrogen-induced polarization in heterogeneous hydrogenation reactions is beneficial for multiple fundamental and practical applications. These include facile production of catalyst-free hyperpolarized liquids and gases (including their continuous production) for numerous purposes including in vivo studies, a possibility to gain deeper insight into the detailed mechanisms of industrially important catalytic processes, enrichment of nuclear spin isomers of polyatomic gases, and more. All this requires novel advanced strategies for increasing efficiency of heterogeneous catalysts in the pairwise H2 addition to unsaturated substrates. One such strategy addressed here is the use of heterogeneous bimetallic catalysts in which a more active metal is diluted by a less active one, thereby providing a structure reminiscent of single-metal-atom catalytic centers of homogeneous transition-metal complexes. Indeed, it is demonstrated that the high hydrogenation activity of Pd metal is largely retained upon dilution in the Pd-Ag and Pd-In catalysts, and at the same time the selectivity toward pairwise H2 addition to propyne is measurably enhanced compared to the monometallic Pd system. Furthermore, In is shown to be a better choice compared to Ag as the secondary metal in bimetallic Pd−M compositions, which is likely associated with differences in the tendency toward surface restructuring, the potential involvement of additional non-pairwise reaction channels, and differences in ensemble effects and electronic structures of active centers in the two compositions. While the exact factors that govern pairwise efficiency in bimetallic structures are yet to be fully established, the results demonstrate that a further search for more efficient bimetallic catalysts is warranted in order to advance this field of research.
NMR data relevant to this publication are available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4436159 (Burueva et al., 2021).
IVK designed the research. AYS prepared the catalysts. DBB performed PHIP experiments. IVK and DBB discussed the results and wrote the paper. The paper was revised by all authors.
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
This article is part of the special issue “Robert Kaptein Festschrift”. It is not associated with a conference.
Igor V. Koptyug and Dudari B. Burueva acknowledge funding from the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation.
This research has been supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Russian Federation (grant no. 075-15-2020-779).
This paper was edited by Jörg Matysik and reviewed by two anonymous referees.
Adams, R. W., Aguilar, J. A., Atkinson, K. D., Cowley, M. J., Elliott, P. I. P., Duckett, S. B., Green, G. G. R., Khazal, I. G., López-Serrano, J., and Williamson, D. C.: Reversible interactions with para-hydrogen enhance NMR sensitivity by polarization transfer, Science, 323, 1708–1711, https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1168877, 2009.
Ardenkjaer-Larsen, J. H.: On the present and future of dissolution-DNP, J. Magn. Reson., 264, 3–12, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmr.2016.01.015, 2016.
Ariyasingha, N. M., Joalland, B., Younes, H. R., Salnikov, O. G., Chukanov, N. V., Kovtunov, K. V., Kovtunova, L. M., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., Koptyug, I. V., Gelovani, J. G., and Chekmenev, E. Y.: Parahydrogen-induced polarization of diethyl ether anesthetic, Chem.-Eur. J., 26, 13621–13626, https://doi.org/10.1002/chem.202002528, 2020.
Armbrüster, M., Behrens, M., Cinquini, F., Föttinger, K., Grin, Y., Haghofer, A., Klötzer, B., Knop‐Gericke, A., Lorenz, H., Ota, A., Penner, S., Prinz, J., Rameshan, C., Révay, Z., Rosenthal, D., Rupprechter, G., Sautet, P., Schlögl, R., Shao, L., Szentmiklósi, L., Teschner, D., Torres, D., Wagner, R., Widmer, R., and Wowsnick, G.: How to control the selectivity of palladium-based catalysts in hydrogenation reactions: the role of subsurface chemistry, ChemCatChem, 4, 1048–1063, https://doi.org/10.1002/cctc.201200100, 2012.
Bae, J., Zhou, Z., Theis, T., Warren, W. S., and Wang, Q.: 15N4-1,2,4,5-tetrazines as potential molecular tags: integrating bioorthogonal chemistry with hyperpolarization and unearthing para-N2, Science Advances, 4, eaar2978, https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aar2978, 2018.
Balu, A. M., Duckett, S. B., and Luque, R.: Para-hydrogen induced polarisation effects in liquid phase hydrogenations catalysed by supported metal nanoparticles, Dalton T., 5074–5076, https://doi.org/10.1039/B906449D, 2009.
Barskiy, D. A., Salnikov, O. G., Kovtunov, K. V., and Koptyug, I. V.: NMR signal enhancement for hyperpolarized fluids continuously generated in hydrogenation reactions with parahydrogen, J. Phys. Chem. A, 119, 996–1006, https://doi.org/10.1021/jp510572d, 2015.
Bond, G. C.: Metal-catalysed reactions of hydrocarbons, 1st edn., edited by: Twigg, M. V. and Spencer, M. S., Springer, New York, USA, 2005.
Bowers, C. R.: Sensitivity Enhancement Utilizing Parahydrogen, in: Encyclopedia of Magnetic Resonance, edited by: Harris, R. K. and Wasylishen, R. L., John Wiley, Chichester, https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470034590.emrstm0489, 2007.
Bowers, C. R. and Weitekamp, D. P.: Parahydrogen and synthesis allow dramatically enhanced nuclear alignment, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 109, 5541–5542, https://doi.org/10.1021/ja00252a049, 1987.
Burueva, D. B., Kovtunov, K. V., Bukhtiyarov, A. V., Barskiy, D. A., Prosvirin, I. P., Mashkovsky, I. S., Baeva, G. N., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., Stakheev, A. Y., and Koptyug, I. V.: Selective single-site Pd-In hydrogenation catalyst for production of enhanced magnetic resonance signals using parahydrogen, Chem.-Eur. J., 24, 2547–2553, https://doi.org/10.1002/chem.201705644, 2018.
Burueva, D. B., Stakheev, A. Y., and Koptyug, I. V.: Pd-based bimetallic catalysts in hydrogenation with parahydrogen, Zenodo, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4436159, 2021.
Cavallari, E., Carrera, C., Di Matteo, G., Bondar, O., Aime, S., and Reineri, F.: In-vitro NMR studies of prostate tumor cell metabolism by means of hyperpolarized [1-13C]pyruvate obtained using the PHIP-SAH method, Front. Oncol., 10, 497, https://doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.00497, 2020.
Chapovsky, P. L. and Hermans, L. J. F.: Nuclear spin conversion in polyatomic molecules, Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem., 50, 315–345, https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.physchem.50.1.315, 1999.
Curl, R. F., Kasper, J. V. V., Pitzer, K. S., and Sathianandan, K.: Spin statistics isomerization in methane, J. Chem. Phys., 44, 4636, https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1726686, 1966.
Du, Y., Behera, R., Maligal-Ganesh, R. V., Chen, M., Chekmenev, E. Y., Huang, W., and Bowers, C. R.: Cyclopropane hydrogenation vs isomerization over Pt and Pt−Sn intermetallic nanoparticle catalysts: a parahydrogen spin-labeling study, J. Phys. Chem. C, 124, 8304–8309, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcc.0c02493, 2020.
Duckett, S. B. and Mewis, R. E.: Application of parahydrogen induced polarization techniques in NMR spectroscopy and imaging, Accounts Chem. Res., 45, 1247–1257, https://doi.org/10.1021/ar2003094, 2012.
Duckett, S. B. and Sleigh, C. J.: Applications of the parahydrogen phenomenon: a chemical perspective, Prog. Nucl. Mag. Res. Sp., 34, 71–92, https://doi.org/10.1016/S0079-6565(98)00027-2, 1999.
Green, R. A., Adams, R. W., Duckett, S. B., Mewis, R. E., Williamson, D. C., and Green, G. G. R.: The theory and practice of hyperpolarization in magnetic resonance using parahydrogen, Prog. Nucl. Mag. Res. Sp., 67, 1–48, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pnmrs.2012.03.001, 2012.
Gutmann, T., Ratajczyk, T., Xu, Y., Breitzke, H., Grunberg, A., Dillenberger, S., Bommerich, U., Trantzschel, T., Bernarding, J., and Buntkowsky, G.: Understanding the leaching properties of heterogenized catalysts: A combined solid-state and PHIP NMR study, Solid State Nucl. Mag., 38, 90–96, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssnmr.2011.03.001, 2010.
Hama, T. and Watanabe, N.: Surface processes on interstellar amorphous solid water: adsorption, diffusion, tunneling reactions, and nuclear-spin conversion, Chem. Rev., 113, 8783–8839, https://doi.org/10.1021/cr4000978, 2013.
Hama, T., Kouchi, A., and Watanabe, N.: The ortho-to-para ratio of water molecules desorbed from ice made from para-water monomers at 11 K, Astrophys. J. Lett., 857, L13, https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8213/aabc0c, 2018.
Hannagan, R. T., Giannakakis, G., Flytzani-Stephanopoulos, M., and Sykes, E. C. H.: Single-atom alloy catalysis, Chem. Rev., 120, 12044–12088, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.0c00078, 2020.
Hily-Blant, P., Faure, A., Rist, C., Pineau des Forêts, G., and Flower, D. R.: Modelling the molecular composition and nuclear-spin chemistry of collapsing pre-stellar sources, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 477, 4454–4472, https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sty881, 2018.
Hu, M.-G., Liu, Y., Nichols, M. A., Zhu, L., Quéméner, G., Dulieu, O., and Ni, K.-K.: Nuclear spin conservation enables state-to-state control of ultracold molecular reactions, Nat. Chem., https://doi.org/10.1038/s41557-020-00610-0, 2020.
Iali, W., Rayner, P. J., and Duckett, S. B.: Using parahydrogen to hyperpolarize amines, amides, carboxylic acids, alcohols, phosphates, and carbonates, Science Advances, 4, eaao6250, https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aao6250, 2018.
Jannin, S., Dumez, J.-N., Giraudeau, P., and Kurzbach, D.: Application and methodology of dissolution dynamic nuclear polarization in physical, chemical and biological contexts, J. Magn. Reson., 305, 41–50, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmr.2019.06.001, 2019.
Kaltschnee, L., Jagtap, A. P., McCormick, J., Wagner, S., Bouchard, L.-S., Utz, M., Griesinger, C., and Glöggler, S.: Hyperpolarization of Amino Acids in Water Utilizing Parahydrogen on a Rhodium Nanocatalyst, Chem.-Eur. J., 25, 11031–11035, https://doi.org/10.1002/chem.201902878, 2019.
Kanamori, H., Dehghani, Z. T., Mizoguchi, A., and Endo, Y.: Detection of microwave transitions between ortho and para states in a free isolated molecule, Phys. Rev. Lett., 119, 173401, https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.173401, 2017.
Kidd, B. E., Gesiorski, J. L., Gemeinhardt, M. E., Shchepin, R. V., Kovtunov, K. V., Koptyug, I. V., Chekmenev, E. Y., and Goodson, B. M.: Facile removal of homogeneous SABRE catalysts for purifying hyperpolarized metronidazole, a potential hypoxia sensor, J. Phys. Chem. C, 122, 16848–16852, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcc.8b05758, 2018.
Kilaj, A., Gao, H., Rösch, D., Rivero, U., Küpper, J., and Willitsch, S.: Observation of different reactivities of para and ortho-water towards trapped diazenylium ions, Nat. Commun., 9, 2096, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-04483-3, 2018.
Knecht, S., Blanchard, J. W., Barskiy, D., Cavallari, E., Dagys, L., van Dyke, E., Tsukanov, M., Bliemel, B., Münnemann, K., Aime, S., Reineri, F., Levitt, M. H., Buntkowsky, G., Pines, A., Blümler, P., Budker, D., and Eills, J.: Rapid hyperpolarization and purification of the metabolite fumarate in aqueous solution, P. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 118, e2025383118, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2025383118, 2021.
Kovtunov, K. V., Zhivonitko, V. V., Skovpin, I. V., Barskiy, D. A., and Koptyug, I. V.: Parahydrogen-induced polarization in heterogeneous catalytic processes, Top. Curr. Chem., 338, 123–180, https://doi.org/10.1007/128_2012_371, 2013.
Kovtunov, K. V., Truong, M. L., Barskiy, D. A., Koptyug, I. V., Coffey, A. M., Waddell, K. W., and Chekmenev, E. Y.: Long-lived spin states for low-field hyperpolarized gas MRI, Chem.-Eur. J., 20, 14629–14632, https://doi.org/10.1002/chem.201405063, 2014.
Kovtunov, K. V., Salnikov, O. G., Zhivonitko, V. V., Skovpin, I. V., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., and Koptyug, I. V.: Catalysis and nuclear magnetic resonance signal enhancement with parahydrogen, Top. Catal., 59, 1686–1699, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11244-016-0688-6, 2016.
Kovtunov, K. V., Salnikov, O. G., Skovpin, I. V., Chukanov, N. V., Burueva, D. B., and Koptyug, I. V.: Catalytic hydrogenation with parahydrogen: a bridge from homogeneous to heterogeneous catalysis, Pure Appl. Chem., 92, 1029–1046, https://doi.org/10.1515/pac-2020-0203, 2020a.
Kovtunov, K. V., Koptyug, I. V., Fekete, M., Duckett, S. B., Theis, T., Joalland, B., and Chekmenev, E. Y.: Parahydrogen-induced hyperpolarization of gases, Angew. Chem. Int. Edit., 59, 17788–17797, https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201915306, 2020b.
Krüger, C., Lisitsin-Baranovsky, E., Ofer, O., Turgeon, P.-A., Vermette, J., Ayotte, P., and Alexandrowicz, G.: A magnetically focused molecular beam source for deposition of spin-polarised molecular surface layers, J. Chem. Phys., 149, 164201, https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5048521, 2018.
Levitt, M. H.: Long live the singlet state!, J. Magn. Reson., 306, 69–74, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmr.2019.07.029, 2019.
Liu, J., Bunes, B. R., Zang, L., and Wang, C.: Supported single-atom catalysts: synthesis, characterization, properties, and applications, Environ. Chem. Lett., 16, 477–505, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10311-017-0679-2, 2018.
Lumata, L., Yang, C., Ragavan, M., Carpenter, N., DeBerardinis, R. J., and Merritt, M. E.: Hyperpolarized 13C magnetic resonance and its use in metabolic assessment of cultured cells and perfused organs, Methods Enzymol., 561, 73–106, https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.mie.2015.04.006, 2015.
Markov, P. V., Bragina, G. O., Rassolov, A. V., Mashkovsky, I. S., Baeva, G. N., Tkachenko, O. P., Yakushev, I. A., Vargaftik, M. N., and Stakheev, A. Y.: Performance of a bimetallic Pd-In catalyst in the selective liquid-phase hydrogenation of internal and terminal alkynes, Mendeleev Commun., 26, 494–496, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mencom.2016.11.011, 2016.
Markov, P. V., Bukhtiyarov, A. V., Mashkovsky, I. S., Smirnova, N. S., Prosvirin, I. P., Vinokurov, Z. S., Panafidin, M. A., Baeva, G. N., Zubavichus, Y. V., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., and Stakheev, A. Y.: Intermetallic Catalyst: Structure and Catalytic Characteristics in Selective Hydrogenation of Acetylene, Kinet. Catal., 60, 842–850, https://doi.org/10.1134/S0023158419060065, 2019.
Mashkovsky, I. S., Smirnova, N. S., Markov, P. V., Baeva, G. N., Bragina, G. O., Bukhtiyarov, A. V., Prosvirin, I. P., and Stakheev, A. Y.: Tuning the surface structure and catalytic performance of in selective liquid-phase hydrogenation by mild oxidative-reductive treatments, Mendeleev Commun., 28, 603–605, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mencom.2018.11.013, 2018.
Oka, T.: Nuclear spin selection rules in chemical reactions by angular momentum algebra, J. Mol. Spectrosc., 228, 635–639, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jms.2004.08.015, 2004.
Ozier, I., Yi, P., Khosla, A., and Ramsey, N. F.: Direct observation of ortho-para transitions in methane, Phys. Rev. Lett., 24, 642–646, https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.24.642, 1970.
Pei, G. X., Liu, X. Y., Wang, A., Lee, A. F., Isaacs, M. A., Li, L., Pan, X., Yang, X., Wang, X., Tai, Z., Wilson, K., and Zhang, T.: Ag alloyed Pd single-atom catalysts for efficient selective hydrogenation of acetylene to ethylene in excess ethylene, ACS Catal., 5, 3717–3725, https://doi.org/10.1021/acscatal.5b00700, 2015.
Pravica, M. G. and Weitekamp, D. P.: Net NMR alignment by adiabatic transport of parahydrogen addition products to high magnetic field, Chem. Phys. Lett., 145, 255–258, https://doi.org/10.1016/0009-2614(88)80002-2, 1988.
Rassolov, A. V., Bragina, G. O., Baeva, G. N., Mashkovsky, I. S., and Stakheev, A. Y.: Alumina-supported palladium–silver bimetallic catalysts with single-atom Pd1 sites in the liquid-phase hydrogenation of substituted alkynes, Kinet. Catal., 61, 869–878, https://doi.org/10.1134/S0023158420060129, 2020a.
Rassolov, A. V., Bragina, G. O., Baeva, G. N., Smirnova, N. S., Kazakov, A. V., Mashkovsky, I. S., Bukhtiyarov, A. V., Zubavichus, Y. V., and Stakheev, A. Y.: Formation of isolated single-atom Pd1 sites on the surface of bimetallic catalysts, Kinet. Catal., 61, 758–767, https://doi.org/10.1134/S0023158420050080, 2020b.
Reineri, F., Boi, T., and Aime, S.: Parahydrogen induced polarization of 13C carboxylate resonance in acetate and pyruvate, Nat. Commun., 6, 5858, https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms6858, 2015.
Rossini, A. J.: Materials characterization by dynamic nuclear polarization-enhanced solid-state NMR spectroscopy, J. Phys. Chem. Lett., 9, 5150–5159, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpclett.8b01891, 2018.
Salnikov, O. G., Burueva, D. B., Barskiy, D. A., Bukhtiyarova, G. A., Kovtunov, K. V., and Koptyug, I. V.: A mechanistic study of thiophene hydrodesulfurization by the parahydrogen-induced polarization technique, ChemCatChem, 7, 3508–3512, https://doi.org/10.1002/cctc.201500691, 2015.
Salnikov, O. G., Kovtunova, L. M., Skovpin, I. V., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., Kovtunov, K. V., and Koptyug, I. V.: Mechanistic insight into the heterogeneous hydrogenation of furan derivatives with the use of parahydrogen, ChemCatChem, 10, 1178–1183, https://doi.org/10.1002/cctc.201701653, 2018.
Salnikov, O. G., Nikolaou, P., Ariyasingha, N. M., Kovtunov, K. V., Koptyug, I. V., and Chekmenev, E. Y.: Clinical-scale batch-mode production of hyperpolarized propane gas for MRI, Anal. Chem., 91, 4741–4746, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.analchem.9b00259, 2019.
Samantaray, M. K., D'Elia, V., Pump, E., Falivene, L., Harb, M., Ould Chikh, S., Cavallo, L., and Basset, J.-M.: The comparison between single atom catalysis and surface organometallic catalysis, Chem. Rev., 120, 734–813, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.9b00238, 2020.
Shinnaka, Y., Kawakita, H., Jehin, E., Decock, A., Hutsemékers, D., and Manfroid, J.: Ortho-to-para abundance ratios of NH2 in 26 comets: implications for the real meaning of OPRs, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 462, 124–131, https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw2298, 2016.
Smirnova, N. S., Markov, P. V., Baeva, G. N., Rassolov, A. V., Mashkovsky, I. S., Bukhtiyarov, A. V., Prosvirin, I. P., Panafidin, M. A., Zubavichus, Y. V., Bukhtiyarov, V. I., and Stakheev, A. Y.: CO-induced segregation as an efficient tool to control the surface composition and catalytic performance of catalyst, Mendeleev Commun., 29, 547–549, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mencom.2019.09.023, 2019.
Stakheev, A. Y., Smirnova, N. S., Markov, P. V., Baeva, G. N., Bragina, G. O., Rassolov, A. V., and Mashkovsky, I. S.: Adsorption-induced segregation as a method for the target-oriented modification of the surface of a bimetallic Pd-Ag catalyst, Kinet. Catal., 59, 610–617, https://doi.org/10.1134/S0023158418050154, 2018.
Stolarov, I. P., Yakushev, I. A., Churakov, A. V., Cherkashina, N. V., Smirnova, N. S., Khramov, E. V., Zubavichus, Y. V., Khrustalev, V. N., Markov, A. A., Klyagina, A. P., Kornev, A. B., Martynenko, V. M., Gekhman, A. E., Vargaftik, M. N., and Moiseev, I. I.: Heterometallic Palladium(II)–Indium(III) and -Gallium(III) Acetate-Bridged Complexes: Synthesis, Structure, and Catalytic Performance in Homogeneous Alkyne and Alkene Hydrogenation, Inorg. Chem., 57, 11482–11491, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.inorgchem.8b01313, 2018.
Tielens, A. G. G. M.: The molecular universe, Rev. Mod. Phys., 85, 1021–1081, https://doi.org/10.1103/RevModPhys.85.1021, 2013.
Zhao, L., Pinon, A. C., Emsley, L., and Rossini, A. J.: DNP-enhanced solid-state NMR spectroscopy of active pharmaceutical ingredients, Magn. Reson. Chem., 56, 583–609, https://doi.org/10.1002/mrc.4688, 2018.
Zhivonitko, V. V., Kovtunov, K. V., Chapovsky, P. L., and Koptyug, I. V.: Nuclear spin isomers of ethylene: enrichment by chemical synthesis and application for NMR signal enhancement, Angew. Chem. Int. Edit., 52, 13251–13255, https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201307389, 2013.
Zhivonitko, V. V., Skovpin, I. V., Crespo-Quesada, M., Kiwi-Minsker, L., and Koptyug, I. V.: Acetylene oligomerization over Pd nanoparticles with controlled Shape: a parahydrogen-induced polarization study, J. Phys. Chem. C, 120, 4945–4953, https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jpcc.5b12391, 2016.